
Dr Richard Emory McGary Jr pleaded not guilty at his ACT Supreme Court trial. Photo: Albert McKnight.
CONTENT WARNING: This article refers to alleged sexual assault.
A former academic at the Australian National University (ANU) has successfully overturned his two sexual assault convictions, with an appeals court setting aside a jury’s guilty verdicts on both charges.
In what can only be seen as a victory for Dr Richard Emory McGary Jr, also known as Dr Rick Emory, the ACT Court of Appeal found he should not have to face a charge over allegations of assaulting a fellow ANU student in 2016 ever again.
However, he may face a retrial on separate allegations from 2020.
At the end of his third trial, the ACT Supreme Court jury found Dr McGary guilty of two counts of sexual intercourse without consent.
The jury heard he and the fellow student, who uses they/them pronouns, engaged in some consensual activity in 2016 before he allegedly sexually assaulted them.
Jurors also heard how a woman claimed they were kissing in 2020 before he also allegedly sexually assaulted her, too.
Dr McGary pleaded not guilty, denied the allegations, maintained his innocence and lodged appeals against his convictions.
“I steadfastly believe that each victim consented,” he said.
He was sentenced to a total of six years’ jail with three years non-parole in late 2025.
The hearing for his appeal took place last month in front of Justices Jon White SC, Andrew Muller and Natalie Charlesworth.
Earlier this month, Justice White announced the appeal would be allowed. He said the court would set aside the jury’s two guilty verdicts and related convictions.
The court then ordered the prosecution relating to the 2016 allegation be permanently stayed. This means Dr McGary would not face the charge related to this allegation again.
The 2016 allegations were used as tendency evidence against Dr McGary in his second trial before he faced a charge over them in this third trial.
Justice Charlesworth, in the appeal court’s published decision, said this meant he was left at a disadvantage in the third trial, because he had disclosed his defence for the 2016 allegations to the prosecution during the second trial when he had not yet been charged over them. As a result, his right to silence was compromised and undermined.
“That unfairness was both foreseeable and avoidable,” Justice Charlesworth said.
But the appeals court did order a retrial on the 2020 allegation.
When referring to this allegation, Justice Charlesworth said the jury should have found the evidence Dr McGary gave in his defence “might be true”. As a result, she said his conviction on this charge was unreasonable.
But the other two judges, Justices White and Muller, disagreed it had been an unreasonable conviction.
Dr McGary has been released from custody and granted bail.
In a statement, he claimed the Court of Appeal found the way in which prosecutors and police conducted the proceedings had brought the administration of justice into disrepute.
“What has been done to me is both unprecedented and a gross violation of democratic norms. Hopefully this will never done to anyone else,” Dr McGary said.
He said the joint judgment focused on whether a limited number of deleted messages in evidence established a perversion of justice.
“With respect, the director’s office and I both know about the other deleted messages,” Dr McGary said.
“When one views the complete body of deleted messages, the perversion of justice is rather obvious.
“As a result, I sincerely hope that Madam Director does the right thing by withdrawing the single remaining charge with haste.”
Region understands the ACT Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT DPP) is considering an application for special leave to the High Court over the matter.
If this story has raised any concerns for you, 1800RESPECT, the national 24-hour sexual assault, family and domestic violence counselling line, can be contacted on 1800 737 732. Help and support are also available through the Canberra Rape Crisis Centre on 02 6247 2525, the Domestic Violence Crisis Service ACT on 02 6280 0900, the Sexual Violence Legal Services on 6257 4377 and Lifeline on 13 11 14. In an emergency, call triple zero.
If you have been affected by sexual violence, or someone you know has, you can report it to police by attending a police station or phoning 131 444.
















Canberra has lots of interesting *real* people that this journalist could spotlight, or real artists… View