11 November 2025

Fifty years since the Dismissal and finally time for a statue of Gough

| By Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
36

Gough Whitlam on the steps of Parliament House, 11 November 1975, while David Smith reads the proclamation dissolving parliament. Photo: Supplied National Archives of Australia.

November 11 is a significant date in the Australian psyche, not only because it is a day set aside since the end of World War I to honour members of the armed forces who have died in the line of duty.

Fifty years ago, the day was hijacked by a Governor-General whom no one voted for, but who was intent on riding roughshod over Australia’s democracy.

Fifty years ago today, Sir John Kerr sacked elected Labor Prime Minister Gough Whitlam, who had almost two years of his second term in office still to serve.

Fifty years ago today, Liberal MP Malcolm Fraser was installed as the interim PM until he was duly elected in a landslide at the subsequent federal election.

Yes, November 11 holds significant meaning on many levels for most Australians.

The Dismissal of Gough Whitlam sparked a political awakening for many, just as it shocked the nation out of its political naivety.

The scene of David Smith, Official Secretary to the Governor-General of Australia, reading – in formal dress – the proclamation of the dissolution of parliament on the steps of the then Parliament House, has long been etched on our collective psyche.

The scene was made more powerful when the newly deposed Gough pushed through the throng to tower behind the secretary as the words were read out.

The late Sir David, subsequently stated he had no idea Whitlam was standing behind him when reading the proclamation.

It wasn’t until it was done and Gough stepped to the media microphones himself that the secretary realised why so much of the crowd had begun cheering louder when he was reading.

Then it was Gough’s turn to utter those now immortal words: “Well may we say God Save the Queen because nothing will save the Governor-General.

“The proclamation which you have just heard read by the Governor-General’s official secretary was countersigned ‘Malcolm Fraser’, who will undoubtedly go down in Australian history from Remembrance Day 1975 as Kerr’s cur.”

READ ALSO Australia sanctions North Koreans over cybercrimes used to fund nuclear missiles

Whitlam subsequently remarked it was the best speech he had ever given at Parliament House and it wasn’t even recorded in Hansard.

The 1975 Parliament House is now known as Old Parliament House, home to the Museum of Australian Democracy.

Today, on the 50th anniversary of the Dismissal, MoAD is staging a program of reflections, analysis and panel discussions of that eventful time.

Speakers will include the current Governor-General Sam Mostyn, former Prime Ministers Paul Keating and John Howard, political commentators, journalists, and even Garry McDonald, who was in character as scallywag Norman Gunston, making light of it all on the steps 50 years ago.

Last night, however, the current Prime Minister, Labor’s Anthony Albanese, delivered an address at Old Parliament House (attended by members of the Whitlam family as well as some of the now old folk who worked in the building in some capacity back in 1975) to mark the anniversary.

And he pulled no punches.

He acknowledged that while Whitlam’s government was by no means perfect, it was visionary, progressive and productive – and that Australia’s democracy was savagely assaulted in the way it was removed.

READ ALSO PM goes into battle for controversial environment laws

“Make no mistake, November 11th 1975 was not a ‘constitutional crisis’ – it was a partisan political ambush,” the Prime Minister said.

“There was no real precedent and no legitimate pretext.

“The Opposition orchestrated a parliamentary gridlock over the budget and then secretly prevailed upon the Governor-General to break it, by sacking the Prime Minister.

“Sir John Kerr justified his actions on the basis of incorrect advice from Chief Justice Barwick, improperly given.

“But in truth, the Opposition had preyed upon Sir John Kerr’s desire to be at the centre of events.

“And they had cultivated his paranoia, his fear that Whitlam was planning to replace him.

“They were aided in their actions by the Prime Minister’s unshakeable belief – right up until the moment he was handed his letter of dismissal – that Kerr was a proper person, who would do the right thing.

“While the scenes in this building on 11 November may have been chaotic, the Dismissal was a calculated plot, hatched by conservative forces which sacrificed conventions and institutions in the pursuit of power.

“And the result of the election that followed does not wash any of that away.”

Mr Albanese used his speech last night to announce the commissioning of a statue of Mr Whitlam to join those of other trailblazing leaders situated around the capital.

It will “commemorate the reforms he drove and delivered” and “above all” the lives and communities his vision and ambition transformed.

“Here in our nation’s capital, Gough’s statue will look out on the public service he revitalised and energised,” Mr Albanese said.

“Down toward the National Gallery he established, and forever enhanced with the acquisition of Blue Poles.

“And it will look out upon the nation Gough Whitlam changed.”

Free Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? We package the most-read Canberra stories and send them to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

36
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

but now we have established the precedent and pretext can we do it again, now is good.

Yawn. What a pointless stupid comment.

If Gough gets a statue i demand one of Norman Gunston next to him.

Richard Davies3:50 pm 17 Nov 25

Great idea and I demand one of Aunty Jack on the other side. Most appropriate.

Hayward Maberley3:32 pm 12 Nov 25

Kerr was leading light in the Australian Association for Cultural Freedom, described by Jonathan Kwitny, Wall Street Journal in his book, The Crimes of Patriots, as “an elite, invitation-only group. exposed in Congress as being founded, funded & generally run by the CIA”. The CIA “paid for Kerr’s travel, built his prestige, Kerr continued to go to CIA for money”.(1)
Whitlam had enabled a royal commission into intelligence agencies, headed by Justice Robert Hope in 1974. In the US, Watergate scandal & hearings had shown CIA involvement in domestic politics, a further investigatory committee was established, the Church Committee, to investigate such.
Actions taken by CIA in regard to Pine Gap which allowed global surveillance, also domestic Australian surveillance, allowing it to monitor anti Viet Nam Farrago & anti US political activity, within Australia all revealed at the trial of “falcon/snowman” spy Christopher Boyce in 1977(2)
CIA extended its domestic subversive activities, the establishment of the Sydney-based Nugan Hand Bank, for channelling money sourced from drug & arms sales into its campaign of subversion around the world.(3)(4)
The Hope Royal Commission made ASIO accountable to the government, thus to the Australian people, upset the ASIO applecart removal of a democratically elected government by initiating the dismissal of the Whitlam Government in 1975 helped ny Governor General Kerr, not the Queen’s representative, but part of the Anglo American intelligence establishment.
Recently revealed the then chief of CIA Counterintelligence from 1954 to 1975, James Jesus Angleton, in the year before the Dismissal already wanted to have the Whitlam Government removed.
Brian Toohey obtained such information from John Walker the CIA chief of station in Australia during Whitlam years. Confirmed by Angleton in interview with ABC’s Correspondent’s Report in 1977 also discussed CIA funding in Australian politics and unions.(5)

That’s all a lot of speculation & has been around for ages.
In any case Kerr didn’t need the CIA. He was quiet happy to dismiss Whitlam to appease local conservatives.

Hayward Maberley11:27 am 15 Nov 25

Specualation?

(1)The Crimes of Patriots: A True Tale of Dope, Dirty Money, and the CIA/Jonathan Kwitny
W. W. Norton & Company: New York, NY: 1987
ISBN:9780393336658
LC: HG3448.N846 K95 1987

(2)Boyce claims that he began getting misrouted cables from the CIA discussing the agency’s desire to depose the government of Prime Minister Whitlam in Australia. Boyce claimed CIA wanted Whitlam removed from office because he wanted to close US military bases in Australia, including Pine Gap and withdraw Australian troops from Vietnam.

U.S. government pressure was a major factor in the dismissal of Whitlam as Prime Minister by the Governor General Kerr, who according to Boyce, was referred to as “our man Kerr” by CIA officers In the cable traffic Boyce saw CIA was involving itself in such a manner, not just with Australia but with other democratic allies. Boyce considered going to the press, but believed the media’s earlier disclosure of CIA involvement in the 1973 Chilean coup d’état had not changed anything for the better.

(3)The Politics of Heroin in Southeast Asia: CIA Complicity in the Global Drug Trade/ Alfred W. McCoy, with Cathleen B. Read and Leonard P. Adams II.
New York, NY: Harper & Row:1972
ISBN:0060129018
LC: HV5822.H4 M33 1972
Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose!
(4)Cocaine politics : drugs, armies, and the CIA in Central America: Peter Dale Scott ; Jonathan Marshall University of California Press,Berkeley. CA :1991 ISBN: 0520073126 LC: HV 5840 .C45 S36 1991
&
Whiteout : the CIA, drugs and the press Alexander Cockburn ; Jeffrey St. Clair Paperback ed., London ; New York : Verso, 1999 ISBN:1859841392 LC: HV 5825 .C59 1999

(5)SECRET The Making of Australia’s Security State/Brian Toohey
Melbourne University Press. Melbourne:2019
ISBN 9780522872804
LC: JQ4029.S4 T66 2019

Hayward Maberley9:01 pm 16 Nov 25

No speculation, as here is proof!

(1)The Crimes of Patriots: A True Tale of Dope, Dirty Money, and the CIA/Jonathan Kwitny
W. W. Norton & Company: New York, 1987
ISBN:9780393336658
LC: HG3448.N846 K95 1987

(2)Boyce claims he began getting misrouted cables from CIA discussing agency’s desire to depose the government of Prime Minister Whitlam in Australia. Boyce claimed CIA wanted Whitlam removed from office as he wanted to close US military bases in Australia, including Pine Gap and withdraw Australian troops from Vietnam.

US government pressure was a major factor in the dismissal of Whitlam as Prime Minister by Governor General Kerr, who according to Boyce, was referred to as “our man Kerr” by CIA officers In the cable traffic Boyce saw CIA was involving itself in such a manner, not just with Australia but with other democratic allies. Boyce considered going to the press, but believed the media’s earlier disclosure of CIA involvement in the 1973 Chilean coup d’état had not changed anything for the better.

(3)The Politics of Heroin in Southeast Asia: CIA Complicity in the Global Drug Trade/ Alfred W. McCoy, with Cathleen B. Read and Leonard P. Adams II.
New York, Harper & Row:1972
ISBN:0060129018
LC: HV5822.H4 M33 1972

Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose!

(4)Cocaine politics : drugs, armies, and the CIA in Central America: Peter Dale Scott ; Jonathan Marshall University of California Press,Berkeley. CA :1991 ISBN: 0520073126 LC: LC:HV 5840 .C45 S36 1991

&

Whiteout : the CIA, drugs and the press Alexander Cockburn ; Jeffrey St. Clair Verso: London ; New York, 1999
ISBN:1859841392
LC: HV 5825 .C59 1999

(5)SECRET The Making of Australia’s Security State/Brian Toohey
Melbourne University Press. Melbourne:2019
ISBN 9780522872804
LC: JQ4029.S4 T66 2019

298 words

The second worst Australian PM ever deserves a statue? REALLY? Talk about misreading the room. Gough was sacked for a single statement he repeated several times that he would “govern without the Senate.” That became the Constitutional grounds to dismiss him and his useless far left government. Further the Australian electorate agreed because the newly elected Fraser government handed the ALP one of their biggest defeats on record.

Some great stories coming out today. Turns out Whitlam’s reaction to being sacked by Kerr at Yarralumla was to pop back to the Lodge and order a nice steak, perhaps even with a wine. “A medium steak with German mustard and a horiatiki side salad” according to reports. Didn’t even bother telling his government colleagues until afterwards.

Mike Willesee asked years later “Did you go to the Lodge and have lunch? You could have been fighting with your parliamentary colleagues.”

“On an empty stomach?” Mr Whitlam replied. At least he retained a sense of humour.

Matt Jorgensen1:32 pm 11 Nov 25

Nope, the withdrawal of Australian troops prior to 1972 was as part of the US policy of turning over defence matters to the ARVN military. That was the withdrawal of combat troops, whilst advisors were still deployed. Whitlam wanted all remaining advisors withdrawn by December 1972, but it took until 1973 for the last to come home.

Margaret Freemantle1:19 pm 11 Nov 25

Gough Whitlam was our greatest PM. He was visionary and made our lives fairer and enhanced the lives of us all

No, no and no! Gough Whitlam like most on the left in government had an aversion to truth. Remember the Kemlani loan scandal? Remember Jim Carnes and his carry-on with staff members? Al Grasby another in that same government with his links to organised crime. On and on and on and none of it in Australia’s interests.

No, I do not remember “Carnes”, nor “Grasby”, nor do you remember any of the construction of modern Australia that occurred in that scant three years after years of Libs who had lost their way (heavily aided by Santamaria and by the Country Party as the NP are doing today). Your massive prejudice will not let you near realities.

Jim Carnes ? Any relation to Kim Carnes the singer ?
Maybe learn to spell before you post.

Capital Retro12:37 pm 11 Nov 25

The only place for Gough’s proposed statue would be alongside Al Grassby’s.

Here we are 50 years later and Whitlam’s Whitlams are still maintaining the rage.

Out at AMC? That’s a bit rough

Why would Barwick’s advice be described as incorrect? And a government that could not guarantee supply was the opposite of productive.

When Whitlam himself had been Opposition Leader a few years earlier, he had threatened to block supply; it was a legitimate parliamentary tactic until it bit him on his arse.

There were two breaches of convention:

1. The failure of two state premiership to replace senators with new ones from the same party. That convention has now been made law, so it will be harder to pull off in future. I note that this breach led to the November 1975 numbers in the Senate, yet in theory supply can still be blocked in future.

2. Whitlam’s failure to either resign or call a general election. This breach of convention led the G-G to use the reserve powers to avoid a complete government shut-down. These situations has arisen at the state level on multiple occasions, except most premiers did the right thing.

The march of egos which led to the blocking of supply was not crafted by Sir John Kerr and, as the current G-G recently mentioned, he had dwelled on the situation for some time before 11 November.

Anne Twomey is an excellent resource on this matter.

Anyone claiming that the actions of Sir John Kerr were an affront to the Constitution have no idea about the Constitution.

Why build a statue to arrogance?

Chris it sounds like you’re channelling Albo’s outrage over the dismissal. The facts were simple – Whitlam had increased government spending from 18%of GDP to 24% and had lost control of the budget. He was on the road to making the country bankrupt, had send government reserves tumbling and had increased spending 36% in just two years. A level of recklessness never seen before or since. See Budget Statement 11 for the numbers.

“The Opposition orchestrated a parliamentary gridlock over the budget”. Any competent opposition would oppose such huge spending measures, then and now.

To this day the dreamers and apologisers talk about his amazing vision and ambitions. Perhaps the Blue Poles purchase was most symbolic of such dreaminess.

Never forget the words of Margaret Thatcher: “Socialist governments traditionally do make a financial mess. They always run out of other people’s money.”

Imagine what a deeper mess Australia would have been in if Whitlam had been allowed to continue the wreckage.

Hayward Maberley3:36 pm 12 Nov 25

Economic and Fiscal malfeasance of LNP from Howard on

1983: PM Fraser &Treasurer Howard, leave Labor an economy ranked 20th in the world with stagflation. unemployment close to double-digits. inflation @ 12.5%, interest rates@ 21%.

1996: Keating Labor leave the Coalition an economy ranked 6th in the world

2007: PM Howard, Treasurer Costello leave an economy to Labor down to 9th in the world. Howard & Costello responsible for two bouts of “fiscal profligacy”, in 2003 at the start of mining boom & during final years in office between 2005 and 2007.

And Lest We Forget marching off on not one but two US Military adventures ,The Afghan Imbroglio @ c.AUD 9 billion &.The Iraq Fiasco@ c. AUD 5 billion both supposedly somehow in the defence of Australia?

2013: Rudd/Gillard Labor hand over to the Coalition the best performing economy in the world, boasting AAA credit ratings after navigating Australia through the GFC (The worst financial crisis since the Great Depression of the 1920s) and an economy that was ranked at 3rd in the world.

2017 – 2019 The Coalition under A, T & M presided over an economy that had slipped back down to 28th in the world.

https://independentaustralia.net/politics/politics-display/worlds-best-economy-2019-no-not-the-coalitions-australia-,13272

1997: Howard & Costello sold two thirds of Australia’s gold reserves. selling at record lows in a buyers market for AUD 306/ounce.

So creating the revenue for the myth surrounding their surplus, revenue raised was AUD 2.4 billion dollars.

If sold now 2025 @ c AUD $5,000/ounce t would be c.AUD 40 billion.

Gough was sacked, but Malcolm Fraser won the 13 Dec, 1975 Federal election with the largest majority government in Australian history. What was that about Gough and Labor being so popular?

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.