27 February 2025

Governments need to be clearer about bringing the Brindabella saga to a conclusion

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
39
entrance to school

Brindabella Christian College’s future is hanging by a thread. Photo: Region.

The net is closing around the board of Brindabella Christian College.

In an experience that can be likened to grasping at shadows, yesterday (27 February) in Senate Estimates it was revealed that the federal Education Department moved to shut the school down last month.

In the tortuous language of bureaucracy, department official Meg Brighton told Senator David Pocock that the department delegate had issued a notice to the board of Brindabella Christian Education Ltd that it was commencing revocation of its status as the approved authority for BCC.

In other words, no funding. Game over.

READ ALSO New leader of Catholic education comes with strong record of reform

That was news to Senator Pocock, the media that have been obsessed with this almost daily soap opera, the school reform group that has been battling the board over its governance and financial shortcomings, and least, but not last, the staff, students and parents who have the most to lose if Brindabella goes under.

A week out from the 7 March deadline and it took questioning from Senator Pocock for the department to show its hand.

Interestingly, a similar question from Region yesterday morning about regulatory action to the department failed to elicit that response.

So while ACT Education Minister Yvette Berry was reassuring the school that she was not going to cancel its registration, the Feds had already acted.

Did she know? We did ask, but Ms Berry is keeping mum until the deadline of her own show cause notice expires on 6 March.

woman at senate estimates

Education official Meg Brighton: “Senator, there are a number of things that would that concern us.” Photo: Screenshot.

But the leviathan lurking in the background, the Tax Office, may be, in the end, the one to swallow Brindabella in a bid to recoup an $8 million-and-counting debt.

Ms Berry might prefer it if the Feds take matters into their own hands, so reluctant has she been to do anything about Brindabella, or at least the board.

With a nearly $1 million monthly payment being made a little more than a week before payday, but teachers receiving only a pay slip but no pay, or only a share of their pay in the bank, everybody is asking questions.

“Senator, there are a number of things that would concern us about that,” Ms Brighton told the Senator cryptically.

Indeed.

READ ALSO Another week, another Genius childcare centre shuts – this time owing $28K-plus in rent

The problem for both governments is that BCC is a school with about 1000 students whose families want a Christian-based education. How will they be accommodated if the school has to close, given other independent schools are full?

Hence, Senator Pocock asked about possible government rescue plans while new management can be put in place, but he only received an inscrutable response.

Then there’s that $8 million question. The Tax Office is not the forgiving type.

Time finally appears to be running out for the board, who may be greeted with pitchforks next time they venture into the school they have led to disaster, unless chair Greg Zwajgenberg, whose Trumpesque distractions are wearing thin, thinks the federal election will provide cover and a Coalition government may be more disposed to bailing out the school.

Whatever happens, there is a need for a full forensic audit of school finances and complete transparency about what has happened.

One wonders what could have been avoided if either government had been more upfront and acted sooner.

It may be the only show in town at present but the Brindabella saga needs to find an ending – happy or not.

Join the conversation

39
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

I think the regulators are derelict in not taking enforcement action within 6 months or so of the school failing to comply with requirements. Why does it take years? Leniency, incompetence, not wanting to rock the boat ….

There are clear regulations to follow BUT those with the power to enforce them have failed to do so for far too long. And I hope taxpayer’s money is not used to cover BCC’s financial incompetence. This is apart from my fundamental belief that taxpayer’s money should not be spent on private schools at all, especially religious-based ones. It feels like it flies in the face of the separation of church and State. I find it as galling as corporate bailouts.

My feeling is the Chairman is not a fit and proper person to hold office otherwise staff would have had their super and pay regularly credited and all govt requirements met by the due date. he appears to be hiding behind his ‘supposed religion”. Not on!

Your leviathan has company Ian.

Quoting from the end 2022 accounts of BCEL (the last ones lodged with the ACNC – https://www.acnc.gov.au/charity/charities/59ad763f-38af-e811-a961-000d3ad24182/documents/ in September 2023)

“The Company has loans with NAB at 31 December 2022 of $11,216,840 and an overdraft of $26,057. These facilities have been renewed on a monthly basis. In July 2023, the Company signed a new loan agreement with NAB. This new agreement is for three
NAB Business Markets Loans with a total facility limit of $10,995,013. The facilities have quarterly repayment requirements and expire in September 2024”

That NAB debt is in addition to the (whatever is the current value, $5m in the 2022 accounts) amount owed to the ATO.

School had previously expanded via capital works completed by Vamos Group

Junior School: https://www.vamosgroup.com.au/brindabella-christian-college
Gym: https://www.vamosgroup.com.au/brindabella-christian-college-gymnasium
Two Storey Building: https://www.instagram.com/vamos_group/reel/C76Q0R-qoyN/

@ Tim Kelly – And these financial reports do not reveal the financial benefits to the chairman, nor any other benefits he gains.

More and more ‘charities’ and ‘churches’ and ‘schools’ are set up so that those running them are the principal beneficiaries. There appears to be very little scrutiny or regulation preventing abuse of the system.

It is always interesting to critically assess the work history of people setting up these organisations, to consider their expertise and motivation for their actions. Often the claims made do not stack up. Trust and blind faith is not terribly wise. Too many people claim to be doing good for other people when they’re actually helping themselves to whatever they can get from those people.

This situation provides a good example for why taxpayers should not be funding private schools, as those seeking to meet their own personal needs (eg enriching & empowering themselves) set them up with taxpayer funds, run them as they choose and don’t put the students’ needs or futures first, let alone those of staff or the local community. This is clearly demonstrated in the case of Brindabella Christian College, repeatedly and with many examples over the years.

If we are to support private schools, there needs to be very strong regulation of those running the show, to make sure they’re fit, responsible and capable for the job. There needs to be accountability for all spending of taxpayer funds, with charities, churches and schools not exempt from basic governance rules. This is to protect the children, parents and staff, as well as taxpayers

There’s plenty of accountability, it’s just that no-one is holding them to it. They recieve $10million a year from the government, they have charity status, … they have to back that all up with audited financial reports. They haven’t done this for 3 years, but no-one is making them, they just keep handing over more money with no proof of where it’s spent. It’s not about being accountable, it’s about the power to hold them to it – ie. give them a grace period of 6 months to show their finances, and if it’s not met, strip their funding… don’t let it drag on for years with no action.

There has clearly not been any accountability as accountability only exists if there are consequences for ignoring the requirements. So far, that’s not happened. There maybe rules about holding them to account, but it’s not happened so accountability has been non-existent.

I beg to differ. The environment non-government schools operate in is already highly regulated and there is, on paper at least, plenty of accountability. However, it does require the local regulator to act and Ms Berry clearly has not – this situation has been going on and worsening for years and could have been resolved long before the actual future of the school is at stake if those with the regulatory power had acted in a timely manner. The sector is over-regulated as it is, we certainly don’t need any more rules.

Martin K & BCC Alerts – Clearly we have different definitions for accountability. Mine is that people are held to account and that consequences follow from breaching rules designed to hold them to account. This is what seems to be lacking. No point having rules when nothing happens to those who ignore them.

I agree with you Martin K.

Maybe someone else needs to step into the Education portfolio. I have no confidence in Yvette Berry who has faced multiple criticisms for her lack of interest or abilities in tackling the ever-increasing issues in the ACT’s childcare and education sectors. She has remained asleep at the wheel during her time as education minister with a number of crises on her watch. The ineptitude of the opposition ensures that she will continue to drag her feet on reaching an outcome for students and families in this ongoing saga which has been escalating for over four years. There is also the uncertainty of staff in these sectors who remain uncertain as to their futures and whether they will be paid from one week to the next.

And a Labor government!

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.