3 June 2025

Greens Senator's move to Labor too cynical, 'convenient' and hypocritical

| Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
26

Senator Dorinda Cox has left the Greens to join Labor’s ranks. Photo: Wiki.

Anthony Albanese is holding his first cabinet meeting outside Canberra today (3 June) since the Labor Federal Government was reelected in May.

The gathering of senior ministers is in Perth and the Prime Minister has a number of reasons to be gloating while in Western Australia, not least that his government fared far better than expected at the polls in that state.

Labor held all its seats in WA and secured an extra two for good measure.

Another reason he will be feeling pretty chuffed right now is that he’s just bagged a Greens defector, accepting Senator Dorinda Cox into Labor’s ranks.

Until yesterday, Senator Cox was the Greens’ spokesperson for Indigenous affairs. She is a Yamatji-Noongar woman herself.

But in a surprise move (at least for the minor party she belonged to), Senator Cox claimed she had lost confidence in the Greens and had approached Labor about jumping ship.

The PM snapped her right up with a hearty “welcome aboard”.

READ ALSO Pauline Hanson’s One Nation savours late surprise and delights in doubled Senate presence

It’s a very cynical move for Labor, and quite a hypocritical and convenient one for Senator Cox.

“As a matter of record, I was a member of the ALP before I joined The Greens,” she said when publicly announcing the move.

“I have reached a conclusion after deep and careful reflection that my values and priorities are more aligned with Labor than the Greens.

“I am in public life to make real change and deliver lasting and tangible outcomes for Australians.

“I’ve worked hard to make Australia fairer and much more reconciled. But recently, I’ve lost some confidence in the capacity for the Greens to assist me in being able to progress this.

“I want to work with a united, cohesive team building a better future for all Australians.

“I feel reassured with my experience, my skills and my knowledge, I can continue to collaborate and build on the existing relationships with an already amazing team of Labor MPs across the country.”

It’s convenient for Senator Cox because her future preselection with the Greens was under a cloud over accusations of bullying and her need to apologise to staff for causing them distress last year.

She has experienced a significant turnover of staff since becoming a Senator.

It’s also telling that she was unsuccessful in the recent Greens party room leadership votes in securing either the deputy leader or deputy whip positions, which she had contested.

It’s hypocritical because just last week Senator Cox joined a Greens statement condemning Labor and its Environment Minister Murray Watt for having “spectacularly failed” in approving the extension of Woodside’s North West Shelf gas project.

Under the heading “Environment Minister Fails First Test”, Senator Cox is quoted as saying: “The UNESCO World Heritage Committee draft decision should have been enough for Murray Watt to reconsider the impacts of this gas project on the WA Burrup Peninsula – but here we are again with some ‘restrictions’.”

Her move to Labor is also pretty dodgy because she was voted in as a Senator for WA in 2022 on a Greens ticket (having first replaced retiring Greens Senator Rachel Siewert in 2021).

She wouldn’t be in the Senate at all if she hadn’t had the backing of the Greens.

Labor certainly wasn’t going to usher her in back then.

READ ALSO Coalition leaders taking flak over firing talent from the front bench

Which brings us to Labor’s cynicism over this move.

Senator Cox joining the government benches in the Senate makes no difference at all to Labor’s chances in passing controversial legislation.

It will still need either the Coalition or the Greens to be onside to get its bills passed.

The Coalition and the Greens, however, will now need at least one independent Senator to vote with them if they are to successfully team up in opposing specific government legislation.

Labor doesn’t need Senator Cox at all.

The reason the PM has opened his arms so wide to accept her into the fold is that deep down he despises the Greens.

Anything that could further wound them will be eagerly pursued.

Mr Albanese was just as delighted at the former Greens leader losing his seat at the election as he was over the former Liberal Party leader losing his.

Unlike some other Labor prime ministers, Mr Albanese can’t abide the Greens or see any way his government could ever enter into any official agreement with the minor party (other than negotiating over bills when necessary).

Any steps to future-proof against ever having to get too chummy with them will be taken whenever the opportunity arises.

And rubbing a bit of salt into the wound along the way only serves to make it all the sweeter for this Labor PM.

Free Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? We package the most-read Canberra stories and send them to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

26
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Looks like Albo’s telling porkies again, there’s been no settlement of the allegations.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-06-04/former-staffer-offended-after-pm-says-dorinda-cox-complaints/105373388

HiddenDragon8:55 pm 03 Jun 25

“The reason the PM has opened his arms so wide to accept her into the fold is that deep down he despises the Greens.”

And why shouldn’t he – but for the gentrification and Greenification of his inner Sydney blue collar tribal lands, he wouldn’t have to be tottering around in public with a tizzy little toy dog with the twee-est of twee names.

Along the way, the Greens and their culture wars influence on the ALP has, though, provided Albanese with some handy product differentiation opportunities and thus won him support in unlikely quarters (who might now be starting to wonder who was using who) –

https://www.crikey.com.au/2017/08/31/the-moment-the-daily-telegraph-fell-in-love-with-anthony-albanese/

GrumpyGrandpa5:50 pm 03 Jun 25

Ethically, I have concerns when a politician runs as a candidate for one party, then switches to another. My view is they should run their term representing the party that funded their election.

It shouldn’t be as simple as “I have reached a conclusion after deep and careful reflection that my values and priorities are more aligned with Labor than the Greens”.

The other issue is does the line between the ALP and Greens become less defined, when Senator Payman defects to the Greens and Senator Cox defects to the ALP?

The same could be said of Senator Price defecting to the Libs, however, during the election campaign the PM was actively distancing himself from the Greens, and now he is accepting defectors.

GrumpyGrandpa2:52 pm 04 Jun 25

Correction. Senator Payman moved from Labor to become an Independent.

Greens need only politicians of principle and guts: they have a big and lonely role in Australia’s future

The Senator certainly took a long time to make up her mind. Why didn’t she do this and get on the ALP ticket before the election. Highlights the political self interest and self preservation that the taxpayers are ticked off about.

@Earthdog
“Why didn’t she do this and get on the ALP ticket before the election.”
Probably because she was elected for a 6-year term in 2022, and is not up for re-election, if she stands, until 2028.

Dont like the greens at all butshewasvoted in by Green supporters, not Labor.

@32roadster
The same old drivel, whenever a politician switches parties or goes independent. Far too many precedents, over many decades, for that to be of any relevance in modern day politics.

Is Labor “bagging a Greens Senator” really a good thing for them ? Not so sure about that, especially when she’s bagging the North West shelf gas project.

Speaking of, with a rare sensible energy decision by Watt (geddit!), a member of the Labor left, does this mean the hapless Bowen is being rolled in Cabinet ? Let’s hope so.

Or has someone in Labor actually put a spreadsheet together and realised how disastrous net zero really is ?

Capital Retro3:26 pm 03 Jun 25

Just as Albo was recently blessed personally by the Pope, Senator Cox has been now blessed by Albo so anyone from the Labor side of politics will be on a one-way ticket to perdition should they critisize the move.

Though what if a critic might also be one those victims of bullying which Albanese discussed ?

Capital Retro4:54 pm 03 Jun 25

The usual suspects are very quiet, Penfold.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.