5 September 2025

Immigration dominates debate in a hectic parliamentary week

| By Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
17
Ed Husic in July at his mobile electorate office

The Prime Minister was taken to task this week by Labor MPs, including Ed Husic (pictured). Photo: Ed Husic Facebook.

Federal parliamentarians were preoccupied with immigration issues this week, following protest marches across the nation on Sunday (31 August) that sparked heated debate and unusual antics over the subsequent four days.

Some of his own members questioned Anthony Albanese for saying good people had joined the marches, which were hijacked by neo-Nazis.

The Prime Minister had strongly criticised the violence displayed in some of the rallies, but suggested not everyone taking part had extreme right-wing agendas.

He was taken to task over his choice of words by some Labor MPs during a closed-door caucus meeting.

But backbencher Ed Husic went further when asked to comment publicly about the PM’s statement.

“I haven’t seen a good fascist yet,” Mr Husic said during an interview with the ABC.

Liberal Senator Jacinta Nampijinpa Price congratulated those who attended the rallies and claimed the Federal Government was prioritising accepting migrants from India because they would vote Labor.

She had to subsequently admit those remarks were a “mistake” but refused to apologise, saying she was pushed into making the statement by the media.

As the Greens accused Senator Price of feeding into white nationalism, Opposition Leader Sussan Ley tried desperately to repair the damage by praising Indian and other multicultural communities.

READ ALSO Parliament should, but won’t, deal with Katter’s violent outburst

Meanwhile, Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young wrote to the Parliamentary Standards Committee urging action be taken against Bob Katter for threatening violence against a reporter while the independent MP was rousing support for the anti-immigration rallies.

“Threats of violence have no place in Australian political discourse, especially coming from a member of parliament,” Senator Hanson-Young said.

“Mr Katter has doubled down because he hasn’t received any sanction. He seems to think that the normal rules of respectful engagement don’t apply to him. This is not OK.

“Mr Katter should unreservedly apologise to [9News reporter] Josh Bavas or resign from parliament.”

Wednesday evening saw the bizarre spectacle of a handful of Coalition senators crossing the floor to vote in support of One Nation’s motion seeking to set up an inquiry into “the impact of high immigration on the Australian economy”.

Bridget McKenzie, Matt Canavan, Sarah Henderson, Ross Cadell and Alex Antic broke ranks to vote with Pauline Hanson’s One Nation.

Shadow health minister Anne Ruston – who had earlier in the day scored a massive win against Labor in forcing the government to release aged home care packages – called across the chamber to Senator McKenzie (the Nationals in the Senate leader) that she should be voting with the rest of the Coalition.

Senator McKenzie ignored Senator Ruston and voted with Senator Hanson, who had earlier been forced to remove an Australian flag draped over her while on the Senate floor.

The motion was defeated 37 to 9.

READ ALSO Opposition forces Labor into humiliating backdown over release of home care packages

A bill giving the Federal Government greater powers to deport members of the so-called NZYQ cohort to Nauru, passed parliament at the end of the sitting week.

The NZYQ cohort consists of stateless refugees who broke Australian laws and, in doing so, surrendered their rights to stay in Australia.

Under the new legislation, the requirement to give such people a fair hearing does not apply in cases where the government has third-country reception arrangements.

The bill was the subject of a hastily convened inquiry on Wednesday evening, during which Department of Home Affairs officials revealed the deal to send up to 354 non-citizens to Nauru will cost Australia $2.5 billion over 30 years.

The Asylum Resource Centre criticised Labor and the Coalition for rushing the bill through parliament, saying it removed the most basic legal safeguard – the right to fairness – from deportation decisions.

The centre’s chief executive, Kon Karapanagiotidis, said passing the legislation sends a devastating message to the migrant community.

“This bill is a racist attack on migrants that drags us back to the darkest days of the White Australia policy,” he said.

“In a week when neo-Nazis are marching in our streets, the Albanese Government and the Coalition have revived a racist agenda we thought had been consigned to history.

“The recent election told us that Australians have rejected this kind of race-baiting and dog whistling, and the decision to revive this kind of politics is an enormous betrayal of our multicultural communities.”

Free Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? We package the most-read Canberra stories and send them to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

17
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

I remember a really big payout associated with someone saying someone else was a nazi because they were at a women’s rally and other people turned up …

Good for you? How is that particulardefamation case relevant here?

Hard to say you’re at a rally calling for debate on immigration if that rally has been organised at least in part by the NSN, who then hijack and march at the front of many of the rallies, chanting racists slogans and committing acts of violence….all on the public record.

What absolute rubbish. By that thinking, marching in the Palestinian march makes you a antisemite!

Sigh Elf. No it’s not the same thing, there will always be bad elements at any politically fraught protest, hopefully they’ll be called out.

What happened on Sunday is the NSN used concerns over immigration levels to at least in part organise marches, they then sought to get in front of most of those marches chanting racist slogans and committing acts of violence, not to mention the speeches….you can’t march behind that and then put with them making white nationalist speeches and calling for mass deportations and worse and say….”Oh I was just there for the debate on immigration levels”.

Well who would’ve thought mixing immigration with a splash of nazism would make for some division. The media is lapping it up, social media is applauding both sides. It certainly creates engagement at the least. It’s not like there weren’t warning signs about the organisers of that march. Yet people chose to attend and in doing so they alligned themselves and the issue to white nationalism. They created this narrative. Any educated person would’ve seen that coming but I guess that lot weren’t exactly our brightest bunch.

Capital Retro11:14 am 06 Sep 25

I assume “our brightest bunch” is the group you aspire to TG?

Who are they, exactly?

“Yet people chose to attend and in doing so they alligned themselves and the issue to white nationalism.”

That seems a reasonable point.

Surely it also applies the other way!

The people who attended the pro-Palestinian marches must have known that there would be Hamas supporters there, and people calling for the destruction of Israel. So thus they have aligned themselves with terrorists.

The pro-Palestinian rallies were neither led nor organised by Hamas, Spiral.

Yet last weekends anti-immigration rallies were at least in part organised by members of the NSN. Who actually chanted racist slogans and attacked people on the street. All of which is on the public record if you care to look.

I don’t think this comparison is as good as you think it is.

There’s quite a lot of emotion in the debate about immigration but let’s not forget the basics.

* this government has presided over the highest mass immigration (over three years) in the history of Australia
* this is despite their promise to reduce immigration
* more people means longer hospital queues, higher house prices, slower roads
* more people means higher carbon emissions
* this all adds up to a lower standard of living for Australians

There’s nothing wrong with Australians demanding this massive influx be slowed and controlled. The Labor government has – yet again – lost control of our borders.

Scott Nofriends2:13 pm 05 Sep 25

Well Said.

Most of that is false.

Proportions.

Impacts (not).

Wrong. Immigration numbers are too high and the intakes from the other side of the world are too high. We need to take more seriously the needs of our closer neighbours.

This is the usual Penfoldian drivel.

“Federal government figures show the NOM for the 12 months to 31 December 2024 was 341,000 people. That’s down 37% compared to the NOM’s peak, of 538,000, in the 2022-23 year.

That record number, covering the period when Labor took office in May 2022, came after the former Coalition “stomped on the immigration accelerator” after the closure of Australia’s international borders during the Covid pandemic, Rizvi said, in a bid to make up shortfalls.”

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2025/sep/01/anti-immigration-protesters-say-australias-migration-is-at-record-highs-but-the-figures-tell-a-different-story

Stephen Saunders10:08 am 05 Sep 25

Yeah, I had that “neo-nazi hate-speech” on my placard. Like, “1.4 million migration, 80% higher than Rudd”. That’s what most of the marchers nationally were on about.

As with The Voice, Albanese Labor has had an absolute birthday, smearing their own people. Very clever, enjoy the victory laps, but also very destructive.

Nazis literally organised and hijacked most of the marches on the weekend. That’s just on the public record both in permit applications and actual video footage.

Sure there were people there genuinely out of concern over the sustainability of immigration levels and many of whom called these thugs out. But there’s no getting away from the fact of these lowlifes getting in front of marches, chanting racist slogans, attacking people and having a platform.

Shame you’re not concerned about people being used by actual Nazis.

Shame on you for not acknowledging the same in the Palestinian marches. Clearly some organisation by pro Hamas supporters and clearly in front of the marches were people chanting racist antisemite slogans. Didn’t see any of the peaceful organizers trying to stop them!

@Elf Hamas is a terrorist organisation. They cannot act in this country in any capacity.

You might not like people protesting for peace in Palestine but that’s their right. As it is the right of reasonable people to protest immigration levels in Australia.

But what’s really shameful is you using some bad elements at the peace in Palestine protests to excuse actual Nazis organising, hijacking and leading protests here.

You can apologise anytime.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.