29 May 2026

Murder trial hears chef had affair with shearer's partner before stabbing him to death

| By Albert McKnight
Police tape

Robert ‘Bob’ Mathew Marshall, 42, has pleaded not guilty to murdering 38-year-old Adam Cordingley. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

Robert Mathew Marshall made a frantic call for help after he stabbed Adam Cordingley in the pitch-black night on his rural farm outside Goulburn.

“I’m just keeping an eye out, because if he comes [back] I’m going to stab him again,” Mr Marshall told the triple zero operator during the call that was played in his NSW Supreme Court jury trial on Thursday (28 May).

“He just lunged at me and started punching me in the head. But I’d seen his car and grabbed a knife out.

“I hope he’s alive.”

Mr Marshall, known as ‘Bob’, repeatedly asked the operator to send police and paramedics quickly.

“There’s blood on the knife so I’m pretty sure I have stabbed him,” he said.

“I remember seeing stars and that when he was hitting me, but I don’t actually remember stabbing him.

“I’m shaking that much and my shirt’s torn off. I’m f-ing scared.”

Body-worn camera footage, screened to the jury on Wednesday (27 May), showed police officers walking down the long, dark driveway at nearly 10 pm and searching the farm for Mr Cordingley.

The officers spotted him lying face-down on the driveway. He was unresponsive and police and paramedics spent 40 minutes doing CPR, but were unable to revive him.

Jurors heard he had three stab wounds, including a large cut to his hip.

READ ALSO Accused 'money mules' allegedly linked to millions of dollars in proceeds of crime

Mr Marshall, 42, pleaded not guilty to murder in his trial that started earlier this week and claimed he was acting in self-defence when he stabbed 38-year-old father-of-four Mr Cordingley on 23 March 2024.

Jurors heard Mr Marshall left the Terminus Hotel in Marulan, where he worked as a chef, that night before arriving back at his farm on Oallen Ford Road in Bungonia and spotted a white ute – which, unknown to him at the time, belonged to Mr Cordingley – behind a barn.

He said he kept a hunting knife in his car in case he hit a kangaroo on the road and needed to put it out of its misery, so took it out before he was approached by Mr Cordingley.

Mr Marshall had an affair with Mr Cordingley’s partner, Kate, which ended about eight months earlier. He had been married at the time himself to a woman named Catherine.

In a later interview with police, Mr Marshall said Mr Cordingley was angry and wanted to talk about the affair, but he repeatedly told him to leave his property.

He claimed Mr Cordingley told him, “You didn’t think you were going to get away scot-free did you?”

“He started asking me questions about what was happening in the affair, how many times we had sex … and what extent she [Kate] was lying to him,” he said.

He said he started walking away when Mr Cordingley began punching him, as well as holding him down and tearing his shirt.

“He probably got three more blows into my head and then said, “Did you stab me?’,” he said.

“By that time he’d let go so I stepped back and ran down the driveway.”

He told police he didn’t intend to stab Mr Cordingley and had the knife as he wanted him to “back off”.

“He’s got four kids. He’s got four young boys who now don’t have a father because I was a f-ing idiot. I should have called triple zero,” he said, clearly emotional.

Kate, the first witness called on Monday (25 May), said she and Mr Cordingley met at the Terminus Hotel. She went on to work at the pub as a waitress, while he was a shearer and quarry worker.

She said she and Mr Marshall began their affair around her 40th birthday in July 2022. Mr Cordingley “was very angry” when he found out 12 months later and Kate originally lied, telling him it had only happened once.

“I didn’t want to hurt him. That was never the intention,” she said.

Kate moved out of their home in Marulan for a time before he asked her to come back, but he also wanted to know everything about the affair.

“He wanted more details. He was always wanting more,” she said.

Joel Cordingley, Mr Cordingley’s younger brother, gave evidence on Tuesday (26 May) and said his brother couldn’t believe it when he learned about the affair.

“He was just blindsided, didn’t think it could happen to him,” he said.

He also said his brother, a regular patron of the Terminus Hotel, was upset half the pub apparently knew about the affair but no-one had told him.

READ ALSO Elderly murderer who killed wife of 70 years died in custody after refusing treatment

After Mr Cordingley learned about it, he spoke to pub licensee Dawn Hogan to demand she fire Mr Marshall. She refused and told him she would call police if he ever tried to speak to the chef at the pub.

Meanwhile, he began speaking to Catherine – who also worked at the pub as a waitress and went on to divorce her husband – more often.

“Just feel like we’ve been made fools of,” he messaged her at one stage.

On Wednesday, she told the jury Mr Cordingley believed Kate hadn’t been honest with him about the affair, so he spoke to her about wanting to confront Mr Marshall to find out what he knew.

On the day of his death, he messaged Catherine and asked if he could go to their property that night.

“I was thinking it might be easier if I wait for him at Bungonia after work if you’re OK with that? Might be easier, save me getting caught on the cameras,” he said.

“Go for it,” she replied.

Catherine said Mr Marshall called her when he arrived home and asked whose white ute was parked behind their barn, but she told him she didn’t know as she wasn’t certain it was Mr Cordingley’s car.

“He said he’d been thinking of going there. He’d been thinking for eight months about doing things,” she said.

The trial continues before Justice Paul McGuire.

Free Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? We package the most-read Canberra stories and send them to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.