26 August 2026

One-star reviews aren't always what they appear to be and they can punish small businesses

| By Jarryd Rowley
Join the conversation
7
latte art

One-star reviews can make or break a small business, but can you tell the real ones from the fake? Photo: Michelle Kroll.

Google reviews can make or break small businesses, with one-star reviews being the difference between customers reaching out and scrolling right on by.

Despite reviews being pivotal to determining the quality of a business and the services they provide, reviews aren’t always what they are cracked up to be. Often, one person’s bad experience can be dramatised. Other times, they’re legitimate.

However, a lot of the time, one-star reviews are used by a competitor to completely kneecap a business, and unless you’re a keen observer, it’s difficult to tell these reviews apart from the real ones.

READ ALSO No more card surcharges, but Canberra small businesses say the cost has not disappeared

Digital marketing expert and founder of Fiber, Kevin Bhadra, explained that reviews are vital to the success of small businesses, with Google often being the first point of call for customers.

“For cafes, mum-and-dad-run shops and even contractors, their whole reputations are built on what people say about them online,” he said.

“Google reviews are the major platform for people to look at, with 81 per cent of people who read reviews reading them from Google alone. That’s a very big market share.

“Businesses know this too, and that means a lot of the one-star reviews aren’t real.”

Mr Bhadra said that while Google is improving the quality of published reviews, it is still difficult to distinguish the real from the fake.

“It essentially has been used, and it still gets used, more as a weaponising strategy by either a group of people or competition than a legitimate way to critique a business,” he said.

“There are multiple different ways people are using this system to work either against the business or in their own favour.

“We’ve had businesses where someone is dropping about four to five one-star reviews from different accounts, from different IPs, and then reaching out to the business asking for money. They often say, ‘We’ll remove that once you’ve paid us to take it down’.

“It’s tough for businesses targeted by these scams to clean up their profiles without a proper process.

“We’ve had multiple instances where we had to hit Google up, saying these are fake reviews or they are not in a customer database, but because they don’t breach any of their policies, Google can’t take them down.”

READ ALSO ACCI tells Treasurer to drop his 'assault' on small and family businesses

Mr Bhadra highlighted ways people viewing reviews can easily spot which are fake and which are real.

“Whenever anyone’s using review farms, it’s normally multiple one-star reviews bombarding one page in just a few days,” he said.

“It’s not very common to see a lot of reviews in a short time, especially all being negative.

“Another is reviews without actual captions or notes. Often, with these farms, it’s just one-star reviews with a one- or two-word description.

“One of the better things Google has introduced is scores for reviewers. They’ll rate who is leaving the reviews based on whether they have left previous reviews and how in-depth they are.

“It’s almost better to check the reviewers’ scores than the reviews themselves to ensure that what you’re reading is legitimate.”

Free Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? We package the most-read Canberra stories and send them to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

7
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Reviews can be purchased for about 8c each in bulk… and they are not written with the foreign accent that helped AI author them… but yeah, you go ahead and believe them all you like. Me, I’ll go for word of mouth every time. PS – for the offended wokes smarting about the word foreign… boo hoo

We ignore all negative reviews and just take the positive ones into account. I have been on the other side of fictional negative google reviews so that informs how we view them.

I disagree. I use the Google rating/ review system both to praise and condemn businesses and most importantly I only give one star ratings for substandard services or products or in some instances both. Although I can see how some may use a low rating/review to settle petty grievances.

Common tactic on Service industry websites is a competitor put up false quotes for work then put up review that work not done or didn’t turn up. When you complain to those running sites they do nothing. Only way to counter it is to do the same thing!

Gregg Heldon1:46 pm 26 Aug 26

I refuse to leave reviews now, especially to businesses who chase one.
I have left two businesses 3 star rating before and both sent me emails demanding that I change it.
I said send another email like that again, and that 3 star becomes a 1 star.
You didn’t have in stock what I wanted. I’m not going to leave 5 stars for that.

98% are justified for sure. Restaurants, cafes, auto repair, hell most business have alllll nosedived in the last ohhh I dunno 5 years since being “purchased” lying to yourself if you havent also noticed.

“purchased” by whom or what in the “last … 5 years”? The current business owners? Those of longer standing?

Small businesses are what they always were.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.