12 July 2025

Petition launched against MP's wild horse culling bill, claims made other animals damaging farmland

| By Erin Hee
Join the conversation
4
KNP brumby fillies.

An activist has put forward a petition to stop Wagga MP Joe McGirr from repealing the Kosciuszko Wild Horse Heritage Act. Photo: Gail Eastaway.

CONTENT WARNING: the following story contains pictures of deceased animals that some people may find distressing.

A resident from The Rock has started an online petition to NSW Parliament against a bill by Wagga MP Joe McGirr that enables the culling of more wild horses in the Snowy Mountains. She has argued that environmental damage is being done by other animals.

Photographer Georgina Gorman’s ‘Stop the repeal of the Kosciuszko Wild Horse Heritage Act 2018e-petition, launched on Thursday (10 July), will be presented by Animal Justice Party MP Emma Hurst. If it gains 20,000 signatures, the parliament will be obliged to debate it. The petition gained just over 500 signatures in its first 24 hours.

Dr McGirr’s bill seeks to overturn a bill by former deputy premier John Barilaro, which recognised the heritage value of the brumbies and sought to preserve their presence in the Snowy Mountains by retaining 3000 horses across designated areas within the Kosciuszko National Park.

“Horses cause major damage to the alpine landscape, trampling wetlands and destroying habitat so it makes no sense to continue with a law that effectively requires that damage to continue,” Dr McGirr said.

The view is challenged by Ms Gorman.

READ ALSO Wagga MP to introduce new law to end protections of Snowy Mountain brumbies

“So the animals that Dr Joe keeps saying that the horses do damage to, the corroborree frog, resides in [an] area of Kosciusko, which is higher than where the brumbies are,” she said.

“The Southern corroboree frog is only found in Mount Kosciuszko National Park in the Snowy Mountains at heights of 1300 metres to 1760 metres above sea level.

“Taronga Zoo has been doing a successful breeding program and releasing the frogs in the wild for many years.”

The Kosciuszko National Park is home to a number of endangered wildlife species and fauna, including the critically endangered corroborree frog, which has a high risk of extinction due to its very small population size, further made worse by climate change, diseases and damage to breeding sites by feral pigs and horses.

While the population of this frog species is declining mainly due to the amphibian disease chytridiomycosis, research from environmental group Reclaim Kosci found the trampling by feral horses significantly impacted the quality of breeding sites for these frogs in 2018.

Wild horses that are not native to the environment are considered pests because of the damage they cause to the environment, according to the NSW Government’s Environment and Heritage department.

“The brumbies don’t go anywhere near the farmland. The farmland is fenced off,” Ms Gorman said.

“There’s wild deer, wild pigs and rabbits that do access the farmland and they do damage.

“The pigs have destroyed the creeks and the water banks; they forage for their food, so they dig up the ground, which destroys the ground and the environment.”

Ms Gorman supplied Region with photos she said were taken in the aftermath of the aerial shooting authorised by the NSW Government in October 2023.

“These were taken when the gates to Long Plain were opened,” she said.

“Carcasses were left in waterways to pollute the water. These waterways flow into the Murumbidgee River.”

READ ALSO Hikers rescued from blizzard conditions in Kosciuszko National Park

University of New England Wildlife Ecology and Conservation Biology Professor Karl Vernes told TuneFM he had seen the environmental impact brumbies could cause.

“[Brumbies] chew the bark of trees and ringbark trees. In certain places in the Guy Fawkes, you find entire stands of trees that have been killed from ringbarking,” he said.

“They create erosion, and can spread weeds throughout the park.

“There are definite impacts that horses have, and the bigger the population, the bigger the impact.

“Wildlife managers aren’t cold, heartless humans. They typically love the animals that they’re studying.

“I’ve flown these transects in the park and I look down at these horses and think they are beautiful animals.

“It’s just a pity they don’t belong here.”

Ms Gorman said she wanted to save the brumbies.

“The reason why I went ahead with it was because of all the media sharing what Dr Joe’s done on Facebook and all the comments were against Dr Joe and his petition,” she said.

Anyone residing within NSW can sign the petition here, which will close on 2 October.

Original Article published by Erin Hee on Region Riverina.

Free Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? We package the most-read Canberra stories and send them to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

4
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

The horses have to be removed for the reasons mentioned in the article. Relocating in the past must not have worked because it is no longer happening, How many people can take on a horse? Those that can already have. I say Save the Environment, the Corroboree Frogs, the pygmy possum, not to mention the fragile snow drainage creeks.

There are plenty of stupid people but I’m doubtful that there are 20,000 people in NSW stupid enough to sign this petition.

Lots of other animals DO damage farmland but it has nothing to do with the need to reduce the impacts of feral horses in nature conservation reserves.

According to this article, the spokespeople against Joe McGirr’s repeal bill, Georgina Gorman, and Emma Hirst of the Animal Justice Party, believe that horses have no significant impact on the park. Really??? In holding to that idea, they are going against a raft of published scientists. There is even a ‘Kosciuszko Science Accord’ on this issue with over 100 signatures (rare for scientists to agree so precisely).

Australia has far more wild horses than any other country, possibly more than all other countries combined. Compared to a lot of native species, horses are ‘everywhere’. In view of that, it is just plain stupid to mandate horses to remain in areas set aside for nature conservation, as well as all the other places.

A raft of published scientists, “follow the money”.

The survey has MORE THAN 20,000 supporters 😤

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.