
MPs poured out lots of love and goodwill to the absent Member for Indi Helen Haines, who remains in hospital. Photo: Andrew McLaughlin.
An interesting juxtaposition on MPs’ first day back at Parliament House after a week away was that while the House of Representatives heard numerous pleas for social media aggression towards politicians to be toned down, over in Senate Estimates public servants were told to stop complaining about their treatment on such platforms.
Normal business was suspended in the Reps on Monday (26 October) to allow MPs to offer messages of goodwill to Member for Indi Helen Haines, who remains in hospital after an alleged car ramming attack last week.
Except for Question Time, which went ahead as normal, the day was committed to heartfelt and often emotional speeches expressing the genuine warmth parliamentarians have for their crossbench colleague.
A number of those speeches referred to the link between a rise in inflammatory social media commentary and the increased risk level of violence towards politicians.
Indeed, Question Time itself even visited the issue.
Another independent MP, Nicolette Boele, asked Social Services Minister Tanya Plibersek what she would say to young women who might be now wondering whether public life is safe for them following the alleged attack on Haines.
The Minister was obviously aware the question was coming and it was a very reasonable one to pose in light of the circumstances.
“We can’t vacate the field to the people who would stop us from doing that,” Plibersek said.
“It’s no coincidence that the explosion of social media tracks pretty closely with the explosion of sexual violence.
“I think if we miss this opportunity to take this time as a turning point for our country, we will have missed a really important opportunity.”
Similar sentiments were repeated in one form or another by federal parliamentarians throughout the day – in morning media interviews, dedicated speeches in the chamber and in Question Time.
The day before, AFP Commissioner Krissy Barrett even discussed the link between aggressive political discourse and the rise in threats against MPs.
Anthony Albanese has talked about it pretty much every day since Haines was critically injured.
The Prime Minister has been calling for some time for the temperature to be turned down on social media.
So it seemed quite stark that in Senate committee rooms, estimates hearings began with a message to senior public servants that they are being “profoundly unhelpful” in expressing concerns about how they are portrayed on social media.
It was a sequel to an episode last month when Defence Department deputy secretary Celia Perkins read a statement before a similar committee hearing that public servant witnesses do not consent to their evidence being shared on social media.
That was jumped on by Greens senator David Shoebridge (before his ascension to his party’s leadership) as an “extraordinary” proposal and he called for advice from the Senate Clerk.
The initial advice that came back was that public servants pretty much had no control over what senators and others did with their witness appearances in the public forums.
Fast forward to this week and on Monday morning Liberal senator Jane Hume asked the now retiring clerk Richard Pye about it again.
The clerk acknowledged that some of the bureaucrats were subject to some “horrendous” and “atrocious” commentary on social media.
But his advice was that “it simply was absolutely not something that a witness can do” to raise the issue in the hearing the way they did last month.
“This is not to minimise the fact that there are some people who have been very bruised by their experiences before Senate and House committees and the treatment of footage that has come out of those,” Pye said.
“ … but it is profoundly unhelpful, I thought, on the day for the matter to be raised in that way without any notice to anybody, not through the secretariat, not to the chair, not to other members of the committee, when the Secretaries Board [heads of departments] had raised the matter in a submission to the Joint Committee on Parliamentary Standards …
“It’s going to require a lot of sensitivity and ingenuity to make sure that in trying to clean up the conduct associated with the way in which social media clips are dealt with, we need to remind ourselves that the accountability that is involved in these processes, the scrutiny … that that can’t be thrown out in these issues – that needs to be something that is given a great deal of weight.”
This is not at all about Pye. He has been an exceptional clerk and deserved all the pending retirement praise senators poured on him on Monday for his professionalism and the high level of support he has provided the Senate over many years.
His advice on this matter is also very sound.
It should be noted, however, that while politicians intensify the debate over how social media is treating them, they should be reminded that they are not the only ones in the firing line of vented anger.
The PM noted it in his speech about Haines.
“We are seeing rage and aggression increasing, not just in politics, but towards workers in hospitality and retail, in schools and in hospitals, towards police, paramedics and other officials,” he said.
So Prime Minister, ministers, MPs, senators, and security agencies, please let’s not forget in this discourse about rising violence that those often very visible public servants might have some legitimate concerns about their safety too.












