28 November 2025

McGirr bill to allow more wild horse culling set to become law - here's how MPs voted

| By Oliver Jacques
Join the conversation
56
Independent Member for Wagga Wagga Dr Joe McGirr said the new law would put science over ideology.

Independent Member for Wagga Wagga Dr Joe McGirr said the new law would put science over ideology. Photo: Supplied.

Wagga MP Joe McGirr’s bill to remove protections on the killing of feral horses in the Snowy Mountains has passed both houses of parliament and is set to become law.

Just before midnight on Thursday (27 November), the Upper House voted resoundingly 19 to 7 to support the legislation.

All Labor, Green and most Liberal MPs voted in favour of it.

The only opposition came from Nationals MPs Wes Fang, Nicole Overall and Sarah Mitchell; Liberal Rachel Merton; Animal Justice Party’s Emma Hurst; and former One Nation MPs turned independents Rod Roberts and Tania Mihailuk.

Dr McGirr’s bill repealed former Nationals leader John Barilaro’s Kosciuszko Wild Horse Heritage Act, which recognised the heritage value of the brumbies and sought to protect their presence in the Snowy Mountains.

“Today the NSW Parliament has corrected a serious mistake. The Wild Horse Heritage Act put symbolism ahead of science and ideology ahead of evidence – and our most fragile alpine landscapes paid the price,” Dr McGirr said.

“Repealing this law restores integrity to environmental decision-making in NSW. It puts the protection of endangered species, alpine wetlands and drinking-water catchments back where it belongs – in the hands of our professional national parks staff.”

READ ALSO What's next for the stallion that rode through Gulgong's ... I mean, Googong's Maccas

Liberal MP Rachel Merton explained why she was the only dissenter in her party.

“Crossing the floor is not a decision to make lightly, but there was no way I could support legislation that will lead to much more of the cruel mass aerial killing of our brumbies and the destruction of an integral part of our Australian culture,” she said.

“Whilst we were not successful, I will continue to advocate for the protection of our brumbies, and in defence of our rich Australian history and culture that these magnificent horses represent.”

Her Liberal Party colleague Justin Clancy, whose Albury electorate covers one third of Kosciuszko National Park, took a very different view.

“This decision is about the kind of legacy we leave behind. Kosciuszko is a living, breathing landscape that demands active care,” he said.

“Protecting it now means future generations will inherit a park defined by healthy rivers, thriving wildlife and resilient high country.”

READ ALSO Should NSW retain this major housing development? Yass Council thinks so

Greens MP and spokesperson for the environment Sue Higginson had long campaigned against the Barilaro bill.

“The legal retention of damaging invasive species in the Kosciuszko National Park was offensive to the majority of people in NSW, and thousands of our members and supporters will be sighing with relief now that this repeal bill has passed,” she said.

“Our precious and singular alpine protected area that is Kosci will finally be prioritised for the native species that can live nowhere else in the world. This is a win that we can all celebrate together, along with the precious broad-toothed rat and corroboree frog.”

Original Article published by Oliver Jacques on Region Riverina.

Free Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? We package the most-read Canberra stories and send them to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

56
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
chrisjeanemery4:55 pm 03 Dec 25

Leaving one feral pest protected was never a good idea.

Pfft…..
“Iconic Brumbies”

I don’t recall at any point in Australian literature, where brumbies were ever considered anything but a problem to be eradicated.
That was the whole gist of The Man From Snowy River.
Get rid of ’em.
And the deer, and the pigs and the goats.

But don’t try to romanticise what has always been no more than a pest.

I find it ironic that the Greens supported this bill…it makes you wonder.

Can’t fix it kill it typical bs

Danielle Kuter7:21 pm 28 Nov 25

This decision is beyond shocking and upsets me greatly – the numbers of brumbies they claim have been in KNP and now exist are far, far less. This has fuelled me even more to keep fighting for this cause and this comes at a time when rewilding  and the use of wild horses to repair landscapes  is taking off around the world, with Kachana Station in the Kimberlys (Australian desert) making headlines with wild equids (donkeys) to create an oasis from desert and prevent wildfires. It’s so good that at least 7 out of 19 of the politicians who voted are not ignorant and have a heart and conscience. For goodness sake, apart from First Nations people, we are all an introduced species to Australia and do incredible amounts of damage to the environment in so many ways, but are we penalised in such a barbaric way??

Dr McGirr you are my hero. Thank you so much for saving our pristine Alpine environment. Science is finally the winner

Load up all the pro horse people & take them up to show them the appalling damage horses do to the pristine mountain habitat with horse droppings everywhere.

Sadly your comment is absolutely correct. Humans are animal’s worst enemy.

Disgraceful, absolutely disgraceful. After the last lot of culling the carcasses of the poor brumbies were left lying around with photos showing this. Shame be upon you and all those who voted for this. I believe this was done on pure self interest grounds. I just hope these horses can be rescued/rehomed before the ACT government performs it’s next revolting cull.

Maybe you can take them home & house them then.

chrisjeanemery2:50 pm 28 Nov 25

Your poll question is very poorly worded and confusing.

Heywood Smith2:29 pm 28 Nov 25

Great result.

Shameful result.

Glad you named & shamed those pollies who ignore evidence & facts.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.