30 April 2025

Dutton labels Barr one of Labor's worst-ever economic managers

| Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
17
Man laughing

Opposition Leader Peter Dutton says the ACT’s Chief Minister Andrew Barr is one of the worst economic managers Labor has ever produced. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

Peter Dutton has continued his Canberra-bashing spree with a rant against ACT Chief Minister Andrew Barr, describing him as a terrible economic manager and one of the worst the Labor Party has come up with.

The Federal Opposition Leader was answering questions on Monday (28 April) about his plan to slash 41,000 jobs from the Australian Public Service.

When it was put to him that Mr Barr had said the Coalition policy could send the ACT into a five-year recession, Mr Dutton let loose on the Chief Minister.

“Andrew Barr is one of the worst economic managers Labor has ever produced,” he said.

“I don’t consider him at the top of the list. [Victorian Premier] Jacinta Allan is first, but he’s second.”

The Chief Minister hit back, however, and put the Coalition’s plans for the public service into perspective when compared with the Opposition Leader’s own state.

“The magnitude of job cuts Mr Dutton and the Liberals are proposing would equate to 450,000 of the 3 million jobs in his home state of Queensland,” Mr Barr said.

“It is a calculated and vicious attack on Canberra to propose our city bear the entire burden of Mr Dutton’s extreme public service cuts.”

The Canberra Business Chamber’s latest Canberra Business Beat survey lends some weight, however, to the ACT’s economy doing it tough.

READ ALSO Clive Palmer wants your vote (and he already has your mobile phone number)

Its report, released a few days out from federal polling day, suggests that businesses in the capital are struggling like never before.

The first Business Beat survey of 2025 shows the number of firms missing their own business targets has jumped from 54 to 63 per cent over the first quarter.

Despite this, the report states, most are expecting their businesses to remain stable or grow over the next 12 months and expect to make a profit.

The No. 1 issue affecting businesses in the ACT remains the increasing cost of doing business.

The CBC’s chief executive officer Greg Harford said the survey showed that business in the ACT was under more pressure than ever, reporting a tough first quarter.

“More than half of all firms failed to hit their business targets for the quarter ended 31 March, with nearly a third expecting their businesses to shrink over the next 12 months,” Mr Harford said.

“The biggest issue for business continues to be increasing costs, and reduced customer demand driving concerns about cash flow.

“Business is broadly split between expecting to reduce staff, increase staff and retain current staff levels over the next 12 months.

“Private sector businesses employ around two-thirds of all working Canberrans, but rely on income from customers to pay wages and other bills and to continue growing.

“Unfortunately, there is a sense that the business sector is underperforming, with 40 per cent of respondents having a negative view of business confidence at the present time.

“There is a significant degree of uncertainty at the present time owing to the federal election and global uncertainty, which is not good for the local economy.”

READ ALSO Holding back costings might actually come at a cost for the Coalition

The chamber is calling on whoever forms federal government on 3 May to focus more on easing the burden on small business.

The latest CommSec State of the States report has also delivered bad news for the ACT, ranking it second last nationally for overall economic performance and last for economic momentum.

According to the report, the ACT economy is being held back by a 54.2 per cent collapse in new dwelling starts; the weakest annual retail spending growth in the country, down 0.9 per cent; and a 3.5 per cent fall in equipment investment over the year.

ACT Shadow Treasurer Ed Cocks described the report as sobering news and said it highlighted the “urgent need for better economic management” in the Territory.

“The ACT has some of the highest taxes, rates, and charges in the country. At the same time, we have skyrocketing debt and the worst deficit in ACT history,” Mr Cocks said.

“Poor economic management has an impact, and we are starting to see that impact in Canberra.”

Join the conversation

17
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
HiddenDragon9:57 pm 30 Apr 25

Victoria leads the nation in state/territory government per capita debt, with the two territories not far behind – so there is substance to Dutton’s assessment of Barr’s economic management, particularly given the latter’s epic term as Treasurer and/or Chief Minister.

There is likewise substance to Barr’s comment on the unfairness of Dutton’s plan to make Canberra bear the entire burden of a reduction of 41,000 in APS staffing levels (if you believe that to be feasible).

The $6.4bn saving on consultancies etc. announced by Labor earlier this week is a sign of things to come if Labor is returned, so even if Canberra dodges the Dutton bullet, the Barr government should be preparing for a further squeeze on federal spending by making Canberra a more business-friendly jurisdiction – particularly as the scope for significant further counter-cyclical spending by the ACT government is clearly exhausted.

For his part, rather than just taking pot shots at state/territory governments, Dutton should be offering practical views on reforming the cost and blame shifting games which federal and state/territory governments play with each other – that’s the sort of stuff that voters should be hearing from a party which holds out the hope of indexing income tax scales without reducing services.

Jon Stanhope would agree. But Canberra voters ignore the many warnings of a former Chief Minister. Ovine Canberra voters, continue to vote for bad economic management in the form of ACT Labor and so we get and we deserve Barr.
For example:
“A homeowner paid hundreds of thousands for their dream home in Canberra. What they got instead left us stunned.
This video captures the full independent inspection we carried out, revealing major construction defects, design breaches, and serious questions about compliance with the Building Act 2004.
We’re not here to speculate. We’re here to show you what was found, what was missed, and why this needs to be addressed.
‪@actgovernment‬ What are you going to do?”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P5qsbyVVHtM

Hayward Maberley4:15 pm 30 Apr 25

Economic and Fiscal malfeasance of LNP from Howard on…

1983: PM Fraser &Treasurer Howard, leave Labor an economy ranked 20th in the world with stagflation. unemployment close to double-digits. inflation @ 12.5%, interest rates@ 21%.

1996: Keating Labor leave the Coalition an economy ranked 6th in the world

2007: PM Howard, Treasurer Costello leave an economy to Labor down to 9th in the world. Howard & Costello responsible for two bouts of “fiscal profligacy”, in 2003 at the start of mining boom & during final years in office between 2005 and 2007.

And Lest We Forget marching off on not one but two US Military adventures ,The Afghan Imbroglio @ c.AUD 9 billion &.The Iraq Fiasco@ c. AUD 5 billion both supposedly somehow in the defence of Australia?

2013: Rudd/Gillard Labor hand over to the Coalition the best performing economy in the world, boasting AAA credit ratings after navigating Australia through the GFC (The worst financial crisis since the Great Depression of the 1920s) and an economy that was ranked at 3rd in the world.

2017 – 2019 The Coalition under A, T & M presided over an economy that had slipped back down to 28th in the world.

https://independentaustralia.net/politics/politics-display/worlds-best-economy-2019-no-not-the-coalitions-australia-,13272

1997: Howard & Costello sold two thirds of Australia’s gold reserves. selling at record lows in a buyers market for AUD 306/ounce.

So creating the revenue for the myth surrounding their surplus, revenue raised was AUD 2.4 billion dollars.

If sold now 2025 @ c AUD $5,000/ounce t would be c.AUD 40 billion.

So do stop believing the mythical economic skills of the LNP Coalition, they are farcical!

Julie Lindner1:56 pm 30 Apr 25

This is the only time I agree with something Peter Dutton has stated.

Incidental Tourist11:57 am 30 Apr 25

No, it’s not Barr. It’s the reckless Greens legacy. Barr mistake was letting the Greens in the ministry for a decade who actually lead the housing portfolio wrecking havoc in the budget and policies. Rattenbury was smart enough to step to “opposition” last year smelling imminent disaster leaving Barr exposed to pay for their errors. Greens are now sitting on a sideline with a popcorn enjoying the show.

How many more disastrous housing reports do we need to read including those from ACT Treasury? Every submission on land tax calculation formula back in 2017 said that exorbitant land tax and rates would decimate the housing market and they did. Both industry and investors opposed to populist tenancy legislation changes saying it will slow construction and it did. Now it’s time to repeal these changes and restore the balance. Yes, it will take time and it requires political will which Barr has. But he knows that only Greens offer quick fixes.

The idea that debt is always bad is unimaginative. There are plenty of good reasons to go into debt, and quite a few bad reasons too. It would be better for this writer to explain what is wrong about what the incurred debt was spent on. If it’s infrastructure, with a return on investment, then why wouldn’t you take out a loan?

Incidental Tourist2:33 pm 30 Apr 25

I did not say that “any debt is always bad”. There is difference between asset and liability. What was purchased for the borrowed money was largely “liability” and very little “assets”.

Unfortunately ACT debt is neither manageable nor productive. Benefits were overstated and drawbacks understated. If you google John Stanhope (formal Labor ACT Chief Minister) you can learn more as to why.

Big-debt-Barr is 100% one of the worst Labor economic managers of all time

Barr became Treasurer in 2011, back when the budget was in surplus with spare cash in the bank. He then used the skills of mismanagement and unaccountability to deliver 13 deficits in a row, and plunge the government into unsustainable debt. This debt needs to be paid back, and currently each Canberran (including every youngling) are $19,000 in the hole. And to make it worse, debt is currently growing at 15% per year.

Worst treasurer ever Andrew Barr is.

https://citynews.com.au/2025/act-budget-shock-how-barr-broke-the-bank/

Barr definitely comes in 2nd behind Victoria which is essentially now a bankrupt state. With $18b in debt for the Territory, a downgrade in our credit rating and $2m a day in interest repayments alone on that debt, we’re going to sink further and further into the Red. At what point should we consider calling in bankruptcy proceedings? For such a small territory we cannot keep spending and spending at such a rapid rate. It is unsustainable

I disagree that Barr is the worst economic manager. He has clearly borrowed some money and increased charges to try to meet some of our ever growing expectations for services. His biggest critic, former Chief Stanhope just kept on cutting services to stay within a tight revenue window. My view is the ACT Government is a financial catastrophe putting off the inevitable implosion on a day by day basis.

Dutton and Barr seem to have a lot in common in this regard.

It’s all pretty hilarious.
Dutton IS arguably one of the worst opposition leaders ever but he is quite correct Andrew Barr is one of the worst ever Economic managers.
I understand that soon the ACT will be up for half a billion$ in interest payments on borrowings – well done Andrew.

Hard to argue. Besides the debt, Civic is now a ghost town.

Capital Retro9:28 am 30 Apr 25

With a Ghost Train.

All we need now is Luna Park.

Far be it from me to defend Barr, I think he’s made some poor budgetary decisions, and allowed some ministers to make worse ones. But Dutton? Pot calling kettle black.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.