7 May 2025

Fear and loathing in Canberra – why do people who hate living in the capital stay here?

| Oliver Jacques
Join the conversation
112
Canberra skyline

How can anyone not love the Canberra city skyline? Photo: Michelle Kroll.

If a Chinese immigrant came to Australia and constantly whinged about how sterile and dull it was compared to his home country, locals would quickly tell him to go elsewhere.

But for some reason, many people who move to Canberra from interstate seem entitled to constantly criticise it while benefiting from its comfortable lifestyle. Moreover, locals seem to tolerate the bagging out of their hometown.

A few weeks ago, I penned an opinion piece highlighting how the capital had improved over the past 30 years and observed that it was now the second-best city in the world in terms of liveability, according to the Oxford Economics Global Cities Index.

READ ALSO ‘Those that survive do what we’re doing’: Canberra club gives up all its pokies

You would think that would be a source of pride for residents to celebrate, but the article attracted dozens of negative comments across various platforms from people who chose to move here.

A few readers asked if April Fool’s had come early, and one guy said I was delusional. Many listed all the bad things about the town they have to put up with every day.

Betoota Advocate has gotten a lot worse lately,” said a Reddit user on my article.

Is there any other first-world locality where people are so scathing about where they reside?

Living in Canberra, I found it was common for interstate migrants to constantly harp on about how terrible this place can be compared to where they were from – Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane or even Adelaide.

Their main problems were that it’s too cold in winter, too far from the coast, housing was too expensive, nightlife was sparse, services were stretched, and public transport was limited.

While these are all valid concerns, they need to be balanced by the many benefits of the city, which are perhaps best explained by the many outsiders who hate it.

Columnist Miranda Devine summed up what a lot of Aussies think about Canberra in an opinion piece for The Daily Telegraph many years ago.

“Canberra is a cashed-up boom town on steroids, with cranes all over the skyline, boasting the highest paid citizens of any city in Australia,” she wrote.

“Smug, entitled public servants live high on the hog, with taxpayer-funded massages, business-class travel, gentleman’s hours, high-class restaurants, cafes on every corner, and a furious resistance to Barnaby Joyce’s sensible idea of decentralising the federal bureaucracy to repopulate dying country towns.

“There’s a saying in Canberra for real estate: you buy Liberal and sell Labor. In other words, the capital, and its house prices, boom under profligate Labor and contract under the fiscally responsible Liberals.”

READ ALSO Public service breathes a collective sigh of relief after PM repeats his respect mantra

You can feel the jealousy radiating off her words. After the weekend’s election result, it’s clear things are only going to get better for us.

If you combine what she says with the fact Canberra has ample green spaces, few traffic hassles and ample live sport on offer, you can understand why we’ve become the envy of the nation.

If you can’t appreciate all that, then remember, it’s not compulsory to live here. To quote Pauline Hanson – love it or leave.

Free Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? We package the most-read Canberra stories and send them to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

112
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
HiddenDragon9:07 pm 08 May 25

“After the weekend’s election result, it’s clear things are only going to get better for us.”

Absent a major economic catastrophe, a federal Labor government is not going to be slashing spending in Canberra in the way that Dutton threatened, but with forecasts for many years of budget deficits, unsustainable spending in major programs, and a dozen, or so, new MPs demanding funding for their electorates, extra funding for Canberra is not going to be a priority.

With the federal contribution to Canberra likely to stay about the same, the real influence on things getting better or worse will be how the ACT government deals with its dire budgetary problems – noting that a federal bail out of the sort which Victoria has already had a down payment on is much less likely here.

I can go skiing on a whim

GrumpyGrandpa7:51 pm 08 May 25

We’ve been here for about 40 years.

Personally, I’d prefer to live somewhere smaller, warmer (in winter), and a lot less political.

The problem is that as you get older, you have greater needs for access to medical services and specialists. So our choices became:
1. Live in elsewhere smaller, and commute back, a number of times a year.
2. Move to Sydney or Melbourne (where we have family), but then deal with the congestion and the big city problems, or
3. Stay here (where we also have family). Freeze our butts off over winter, tolerate the strong political opinions, but live somewhere that has a lot of the benefits of larger cities, but with less of the negatives.

We tossed up moving, but concluded, that it was better to stay with the devil we knew…

“and a lot less political”…and ….” tolerate the strong political opinions” what does this even mean? Are you saying you’re unhappy living somewhere that people vote differently than you would prefer? lol

“Barnaby Joyce’s sensible idea of decentralising the federal bureaucracy to repopulate dying country towns.”

Even for Barnaby this was a dumb idea (little wonder Miranda was a fan, not one of the great thinkers), the whole point of Canberra is the efficiencies of a centralised bureaucracy.

Barnaby’s plan wasn’t about fixing regional Australia (if it was it would have been more carrot and less stick) it was about attacking Canberra in the same way Peter Dutton’s cuts to the APS were and it’s one reason why it didn’t work. IDK why the hard right hate Canberra so much but they need to get over it.

It was better 20 years ago when we had affordable homes for first home buyers on decent sized blocks, a hospital without excessive waiting times, uncongested roads and no tram, reasonable rates and no Barr.

In response to the ‘Pauline Hanson’ line of “if you don’t love it, leave” It’d leave but sadly I don’t have the means to.

I agree. Difficult to put into precise words. Canberra is like life in monochrome compared to full colour in my home city, Adelaide. Yes, partly it’s all the SMUG, labour voting public servants which make hay when spendthrift Labour is in power, as they run up national debt. Overall not a place which makes me want to get up and about in retirement. Just returned from 2 months in Adelaide where I was up and about every day doing different things. Why do I stat? Family. And in any case, I can’t afford a move.

A friend from Brisbane point out that Canberra’s a place you move to for work or study (not the lifestyle) and get stuck there. Someone else point out “they always move back to where they came from originally (Sydney or Melbourne).” Canberra’s improved over the years but the culture is still a bit conservative and communication isn’t great (I made enquiries about joining a local community group 2 years ago and still haven’t heard back). When people complain and want to leave the problem is it’s harder to leave, where will they go? What will they do? How much is real estate elsewhere?

Kirsten Anker1:53 pm 08 May 25

As part of the recent Canberra International Music Festival, the narrator of a piece reminded us that residents of Canberra have to get use dot living with Utopian ideals. Burley Griffin planned a city that drew on international examples to provide livable spaces for residents and that embodied democratic principles. Since building began on the city, those ideals have been frustrated by planners who did not fully understand or were not willing to engage with the plan at this level. I will continue to complain about aspects of the city that move us away from rather than towards the vision of Marion Mahony and Walter Burley Griffin.

Peter Graves2:52 pm 08 May 25

Thanks for those welcome reminders of the Griffins. Some time next year, we are likely to be able to “see” them, as the National Capital Authority is funding a commemoration of Marion Mahony Griffin and Walter Burley Griffin. The commemoration will recognise the contribution the two architects made to the design of Canberra – the national capital. It will also acknowledge the broader contribution of the Griffins to city planning, architecture, and landscape design.

More at https://www.nca.gov.au/commemoration-marion-mahony-griffin-and-walter-burley-griffin#

Kristina Ricardo1:33 pm 08 May 25

“Their main problems were that it’s too cold in winter, too far from the coast, housing was too expensive, nightlife was sparse, services were stretched, and public transport was limited.” How come the article didn’t simply end after this bit of accurate explanation?

Incidental Tourist1:09 pm 08 May 25

Every time I drive past its smug Penis Owl sculpture I can’t help thinking of cast in stone thought bubble and unique combination of professionalism and incompetence.

devils_advocate12:47 pm 08 May 25

“Ah, so you criticise society, and yet you choose to participate in it – curious!

…I am very intelligent.”

Peter Graves10:52 am 08 May 25

I came here in 1972 (declaration: in the APS) and suggest it’s necessary to:
(1) never ever quote any Murdoch publication and its “commentaters” on Canberra;
(2) distinguish between the built environment of Canberra and its suburbs, and
(3) appreciate the distinction between the unplanned (messy) natures of the state capitals and Canberra being one of the few planned national capitals and designed as such;
(4) get over the comparisons between Sydney and Melbourne as the (better) cities;
(5) appreciate Canberra as the capital of Australia and the place of its national Government – to which ALL Australian voters send their representatives.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Region Canberra stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.